- IRI:
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures
- Version IRI:
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures/2018-07-13

- Date :
- 13/07/2018
- Current version :
- 1.1
- Previous version :
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures/2015-07-13 (visualise it with LODE )

- Authors :
- Idafen Santana-Pérez
- María Poveda-Villalón
- Silvio Peroni
- Contributors :
- Aliaksandr Birukou

- Imported Ontologies :
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-core (visualise it with LODE )

- Other visualisation :
- Ontology source - WebVowl

This work is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).

- academic event
- concept scheme
- conference ranking
- conference ranking category
- discrete review rating scale
- discrete reviewer confidence scale
- expression
- peer review type
- review rating scale
- review rating value
- reviewer confidence scale
- reviewer confidence value
- scholarly venue management system

**IRI:** http://data.semanticweb.org/ns/swc/ontology#AcademicEvent

- is defined by
- http://data.semanticweb.org/ns/swc/ontology

Any academic event such as conferences, workshops, symposia.

**IRI:** http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#ConceptScheme

- is defined by
- http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core

- has sub-classes
- conference ranking
^{c}, review rating scale^{c}, reviewer confidence scale^{c} - is in range of
- is defined in ranking
^{op}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ConferenceRanking

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

This class describes conference rankings as composed by categories identifying different rankings.

- has super-classes
- concept scheme
^{c} - has members
- CORE conference ranking
^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ConferenceRankingCategory

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

This class identifies all the possible categories that can be used for ranking a conference according to the related ranking that defines them.

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/DiscreteReviewRatingScale

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

A discrete scale defining the rating given by a reviewer for a specific scientific contribution.

- has super-classes
- review rating scale
^{c} - has members
- Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale
^{ni}, Approved to Not Approved review rating scale^{ni}, Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale^{ni}, Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale^{ni}, Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale^{ni}, Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale^{ni}, Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/DiscreteReviewerConfidenceScale

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

A discrete scale defining the confidence of a reviewer for a given topic.

- has super-classes
- reviewer confidence scale
^{c} - has members
- Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale
^{ni}, Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/fabio/Expression

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/fabio

Any possible work such as journals, magazines, books, etc., created for scientific purposes and possibily related with review processes.

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/PeerReviewType

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

This class describes different kinds of peer review processes, such as double-blind and open.

- has super-classes
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - inverse with bibliometric data
^{op}only inverse holds bibliometric data in time^{op}only academic event^{c}or expression^{c} - has members
- double blind peer review
^{ni}, open peer review^{ni}, single blind peer review^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ReviewRatingScale

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

A scale defining the rating given by a reviewer for a specific scientific contribution.

- has super-classes
- concept scheme
^{c} - has sub-classes
- discrete review rating scale
^{c} - has members
- 0 to 10 continuos review rating scale
^{ni}, 0 to 15 continuos review rating scale^{ni}, to 5 continuos^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ReviewRatingValue

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

This class describes the set of values compliant with a given review rating scale.

- has super-classes
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - is in domain of
- has rating value
^{dp} - has members
- -1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)
^{ni}, -2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)^{ni}, 0 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)^{ni}, 0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)^{ni}, 1 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)^{ni}, 2 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 2 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 3 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 4 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 5 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 6 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 7 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 8 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, 9 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)^{ni}, Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)^{ni}, Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)^{ni}, Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)^{ni}, Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)^{ni}, Borderline (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Major revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)^{ni}, Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)^{ni}, Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)^{ni}, Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)^{ni}, Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)^{ni}, Reject, Pre-Screening (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)^{ni}, Reject, Two Strikes (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)^{ni}, Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)^{ni}, Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)^{ni}, Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)^{ni}, Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)^{ni}, Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ReviewerConfidenceScale

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

A scale defining the confidence of a reviewer for a given topic.

- has super-classes
- concept scheme
^{c} - has sub-classes
- discrete reviewer confidence scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ReviewerConfidenceValue

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

This class describes the set of values compliant with a given reviewer confidence scale.

- has super-classes
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - is in domain of
- has confidence value
^{dp} - has members
- 1 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)
^{ni}, 2 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 3 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 4 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, 5 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)^{ni}, Expert (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)^{ni}, High (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)^{ni}, Low (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)^{ni}, Medium (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)^{ni}, Null (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)^{ni}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ScholarlyVenueManagementSystem

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

This class describes all the possible venue management systems (such as conference management systems and journal management systems) that can be used for managing scholarly venues.

- has super-classes
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - inverse with bibliometric data
^{op}only inverse holds bibliometric data in time^{op}only academic event^{c}or expression^{c} - has members
- Conference Management Toolkit
^{ni}, EasyChair^{ni}

**IRI:** http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#closeMatch

- is defined by
- http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core

**IRI:** http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#inScheme

- is defined by
- http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core

- has sub-properties
- is defined in ranking
^{op}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/isDefinedIn

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It links a ranking category with the ranking that defines it.

- has super-properties
- in scheme
^{op} - has domain
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - has range
- concept scheme
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/isHigherThan

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It links a ranking category with one that is less important.

- has domain
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - has range
- categorial bibliometric data
^{c} - is inverse of
- is lower than
^{op}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/isLowerThan

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It links a ranking category with one that is more important.

- is inverse of
- is higher than
^{op}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/hasConfidenceValue

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The confidence value of expertise in the review topic given by the reviwer.

- has domain
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has range
- literal

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/hasRatingValue

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The value of the rating given to a review.

- has domain
- review rating value
^{c} - has range
- literal

- -1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)
- -2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)
- 0 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)
- 0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)
- 0 to 10 continuos review rating scale
- 0 to 15 continuos review rating scale
- 1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)
- 1 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)
- 1 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)
- 10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale)
- 2 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 2 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)
- 2 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)
- 3 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)
- 3 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)
- 4 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)
- 4 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)
- 5 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale)
- 5 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale)
- 6 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 7 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 8 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- 9 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale)
- A
- A*
- Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)
- Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)
- Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale
- Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)
- Approved to Not Approved review rating scale
- Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)
- average number of reviews per paper
- B
- Borderline (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- C
- Conference Management Toolkit
- CORE conference ranking
- Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale
- Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale
- Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale
- Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale
- double blind peer review
- EasyChair
- Expert (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)
- Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale
- High (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)
- Low (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)
- Major revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)
- Medium (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)
- Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)
- Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale)
- Null (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale)
- number of demo paper accepted
- number of external reviewers involved
- number of full paper accepted
- number of poster paper accepted
- number of short paper accepted
- number of submission sent for review
- open peer review
- Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)
- Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)
- Reject, Pre-Screening (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)
- Reject, Two Strikes (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale)
- single blind peer review
- Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)
- Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)
- Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale
- Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale
- to 5 continuos
- unranked
- Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)
- Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale)
- Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale)

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-n2-p2-neg1

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"-1"^^int - close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-n2-p2-neg2

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"-2"^^int - close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-n2-p2-0

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"0"^^int - close match
^{op}Major revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Borderline (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-0

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"0"^^int - close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5-0

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"0"^^int - close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/to-10-continuos

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/to-15-continuos

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-n2-p2-pos1

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"1"^^int - close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-1

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"1"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5-1

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"1"^^int - close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/acl-1-5-acl1

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Not reviewer's area of expertise, or paper is very hard to understand. The evaluation is just an educated guess.

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"1"^^int - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Null (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-10

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"10"^^int - close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-n2-p2-pos2

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"2"^^int - close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-2

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"2"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5-2

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"2"^^int - close match
^{op}Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/acl-1-5-acl2

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Reviewers is willing to defend my evaluation, but it is fairly likely that he/she missed some details, didn't understand some central points, or can't be sure about the novelty of the work.

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"2"^^int - close match
^{op}2 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Low (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-3

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"3"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5-3

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"3"^^int - close match
^{op}Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/acl-1-5-acl3

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Reviewer is pretty sure, but there's a chance he/she missed something. Although she/he has a good feel for this area in general, she/he did not carefully check the paper's details, e.g., the math, experimental design, or novelty.

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"3"^^int - close match
^{op}3 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Medium (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-4

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"4"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5-4

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"4"^^int - close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/acl-1-5-acl4

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Reviewer is quite sure, tried to check the important points carefully. It's unlikely, though conceivable, that he/she missed something that should affect his/her ratings.

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"4"^^int - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}High (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-5

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"5"^^int - close match
^{op}Major revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Borderline (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5-5

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"5"^^int - close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/acl-1-5-acl5

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Reviewer is positive that the evaluation is correct, has read the paper very carefully and is familiar with related work.

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"5"^^int - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Expert (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-6

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"6"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-7

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"7"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-8

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"8"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10-9

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- has rating value
^{dp}"9"^^int - in scheme
^{op}Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/core-a

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The CORE category for an excellent conference, and highly respected in a discipline area.

- belongs to
- conference ranking category
^{c} - has facts
- is defined in ranking
^{op}CORE conference ranking - is higher than
^{op}B

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/core-a-star

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The CORE category for a flagship conference, a leading venue in a discipline area.

- belongs to
- conference ranking category
^{c} - has facts
- is defined in ranking
^{op}CORE conference ranking - is higher than
^{op}A

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts-acc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-acc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb-acc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from Accept to Reject, including pre-screening and two strikes rule

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-na-wr-app

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Approved to Not Approved review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-na-wr

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from Approved to Not Approved, including Aprproved With Reservations.

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-na-wr-appwr

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Approved to Not Approved review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/average-of-reviews-per-paper

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many reviewers has been used for each paper submitted to a venue.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/core-b

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The CORE category for a good conference, and well regarded in a discipline area.

- belongs to
- conference ranking category
^{c} - has facts
- is defined in ranking
^{op}CORE conference ranking - is higher than
^{op}C

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-bdl

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Major revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/core-c

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The CORE category for other ranked conference venues that meet minimum standards.

- belongs to
- conference ranking category
^{c} - has facts
- is defined in ranking
^{op}CORE conference ranking - is higher than
^{op}unranked

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/conference-management-toolkit

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The Conference Management Toolkit (CMT) is a free conference management service sponsored by Microsoft Research.

- belongs to
- scholarly venue management system
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/core-conference-ranking

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The CORE Conference Ranking (http://www.core.edu.au/index.php/conference-rankings) is an ongoing activity that provides assessments of major conferences in the computing disciplines.The rankings are managed by the CORE Executive Committee, with updates processed from time to time by a subcommittee established as needed.

- belongs to
- conference ranking
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-n2-p2

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from -2 to 2, including 0

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-10

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from 0 to 10

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/dis-0-5

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from 0 to 5

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/acl-1-5

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from 1 to 5, used by Association for Computational Linguistics annual meetings

- belongs to
- discrete reviewer confidence scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/double-blind-peer-review

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It identifies all the review processes where the identity of the authors is concealed from the reviewers, and vice versa.

- belongs to
- peer review type
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/easychair

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

EasyChair is a conference management system that is flexible, easy to use, and has many features to make it suitable for various conference models. It is currently probably the most commonly used conference management system.

- belongs to
- scholarly venue management system
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ex-null-exp

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"4"^^int - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Expert (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ex-null

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from Expert to Null, also representend in an scale from 4 to 0

- belongs to
- discrete reviewer confidence scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ex-null-high

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"3"^^int - close match
^{op}4 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}High (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ex-null-low

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"1"^^int - close match
^{op}2 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Low (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts-majrev

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}5 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Borderline (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ex-null-med

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"2"^^int - close match
^{op}3 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Medium (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts-minrev

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-na-wr-napp

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Approved to Not Approved review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/ex-null-null

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- reviewer confidence value
^{c} - has facts
- has confidence value
^{dp}"0"^^int - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 1 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Null (Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale) - in scheme
^{op}Expert to Null reviewer confidence scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/demo-paper-accepted

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many demo papers has been accepted for publication/presentation in the venue.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/external-reviewers-involved

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many external reviewers have been involved in the reviewing phase.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/full-papers-accepted

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many full papers has been accepted for publication/presentation in the venue.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/poster-papers-accepted

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many poster papers has been accepted for publication/presentation in the venue.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/short-papers-accepted

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many short papers has been accepted for publication/presentation in the venue.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/submissions-sent-for-review

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It indicates how many submitted papers has been assagned to reviewers for revision.

- belongs to
- bibliometric measure
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/open-peer-review

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It identifies all the review processes where the identity of the authors and the reviewers is known.

- belongs to
- peer review type
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts-rej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-rej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb-rej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}1 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-1 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts-rejps

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- in scheme
^{op}Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/a-r-ts-rejts

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- in scheme
^{op}Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/single-blind-peer-review

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

It identifies all the review processes where the identity of the reviewers is concealed from the authors.

- belongs to
- peer review type
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-sacc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb-sacc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Accept (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}10 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}5 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-srej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb-srej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Not approved (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Reject (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 10 (Discrete 0 to 10 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}0 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}-2 on a [-2,2] scale (Discrete -2 to 2 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Strong Reject (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from Strong Reject to Strong Accept, including Bordeline

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

Discrete scale from Strong Reject to Strong Accept, excluding Bordeline

- belongs to
- discrete review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/to-5-continuos

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating scale
^{c}

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/core-unranked

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

The CORE category for a conference for which no ranking decision has been made.

- belongs to
- conference ranking category
^{c} - has facts
- is defined in ranking
^{op}CORE conference ranking

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-wacc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb-wacc

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

- belongs to
- review rating value
^{c} - has facts
- close match
^{op}Approved with reservations (Approved to Not Approved review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Minor revision (Accept to Reject, Two Strikes review rating scale) - close match
^{op}3 out of 5 (Discrete 0 to 5 review rating scale) - close match
^{op}Weak Accept (Strong Reject to Strong Accept review rating scale) - in scheme
^{op}Strong Reject to Strong Accept, without Borderline review rating scale

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-bl-wrej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

**IRI:** http://purl.org/spar/bido/sa-sr-nb-wrej

- is defined by
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures

**IRI:** http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel

*default namespace*- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures#
- bido
- http://purl.org/spar/bido/
- bido-review-measures
- http://purl.org/spar/bido-review-measures/
- cpannotationschema
- http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl#
- dc
- http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/
- fabio
- http://purl.org/spar/fabio/
- ontology
- http://data.semanticweb.org/ns/swc/ontology#
- owl
- http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#
- rdf
- http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#
- rdflicense
- http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/
- rdfs
- http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#
- skos
- http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#
- spar
- http://purl.org/spar/
- swc
- http://data.semanticweb.org/ns/swc/
- terms
- http://purl.org/dc/terms/
- xsd
- http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#

This HTML document was obtained by processing the OWL ontology source code through LODE, *Live OWL Documentation Environment*, developed by Silvio Peroni
.